It was quite a shock going from the old paladin armor to the judgement gear when it came out. Still some of the best tiers in the game imo.
The reaction of warriors would have been amusing I think.
/logs onto wow: 'MY SHOULDERS ARE MADE OF AXES. WHY ARE MY SHOULDERS MADE OF AXES? OW. I HAVE CUT MYSELF.' And the helmet that looks like a bastard child of Robocop and a can opener.