Senior Game Designer Josh Greenfield explained the discovery philosophy in a new MMORPG.com interview about World of Warcraft: Forever. Blizzard is obfuscating item information so that an item’s stats remain hidden until somebody actually obtains it on that server. Once players begin finding those items, databases and guides can naturally fill themselves in, but the developers want that knowledge to come from playing Forever rather than extracting its files before launch.
That creates something World of Warcraft has not reliably possessed for a very long time.
A first week where nobody really knows.
Your BiS List Has to Wait for the Loot to Exist
This is a fascinating extension of the massive Forever loot overhaul we covered earlier this week. Blizzard has already re-examined every dungeon drop, added hundreds of new rewards, improved world-drop epics and expanded quest rewards for different roles.
Normally, most of that mystery would last approximately until the first serious datamining pass.
Forever is actively trying to prevent that.
If a new raid contains a caster trinket with a strange proc, players should learn what it does because somebody killed the boss and watched it land in a backpack. If a blue item from an older dungeon turns out to be unexpectedly brilliant against dragons, that information has to spread through the community after discovery rather than appearing in a spreadsheet weeks before anybody enters the dungeon.
There will still be guides.
There will still be Best in Slot lists.
There will absolutely still be people arguing about whether a 0.7 percent theoretical upgrade justifies ruining everybody’s evening.
They simply have to discover the items first.
Forever Raids Are Supposed to Begin Unsolved
The same philosophy extends to raids themselves.
Blizzard wants players entering Forever raids without already knowing every encounter. Greenfield says players should not know exactly which bosses they will fight before entering for the first time, and there will not initially be a Dungeon Journal explaining every ability and encounter mechanic.
Blizzard is also avoiding the traditional raid PTR process that has allowed Modern WoW guilds, guide writers and analysts to spend weeks dissecting encounters before they reach live servers.
That is a huge philosophical departure.
Modern raid testing exists for good reasons. Thousands of players hitting bosses on PTR generates extraordinary amounts of balance data and exposes bugs before progression begins. The tradeoff is that genuinely new raid encounters rarely feel entirely new anymore.
Forever is choosing more mystery and accepting some of the risk that comes with it.
Blizzard Is Trying to Recreate Discovery, Not Ignorance
There is an important distinction here.
Blizzard is not trying to permanently prevent players from sharing information. Forever will still have addons, websites, databases, theorycrafting communities and guides. We already know that Forever will restrict computational combat addons, but ordinary interface customization and community tools remain part of the game.
Once players discover something, they can document it.
That is intentional.
The goal is to restore the period before the answer becomes common knowledge.
Original WoW had that period naturally because nobody had spent twenty years building tools capable of extracting and analyzing practically everything Blizzard shipped. Forever has to manufacture the same uncertainty deliberately.
And that fits remarkably well with Forever’s entire Classic+ philosophy. Blizzard cannot erase our memories of Azeroth. Westfall is still Westfall. Scarlet Monastery is still Scarlet Monastery. We know where Ironforge is unless something has gone very badly wrong.
But Blizzard can hide the new parts until we actually encounter them.
The Forever Beta Already Shows the System Working
The timing is especially interesting because the Forever beta is now live with its initial level 20 cap, and dataminers are already tearing into the client.
We have seen mounts, spell names and other assets emerge from the files. Item stats, however, are being deliberately obscured. Wowhead has already responded by encouraging beta players to upload actual in-game discoveries through its client because the normal datamining route cannot simply reveal everything in advance.
For once, the database needs adventurers.
That feels oddly appropriate.
The First Raid Week Could Actually Be the Wild West
Greenfield described the opening raid period as potentially becoming something close to the Wild West, and that may be the most exciting part of the idea.
Imagine a new weapon drops.
Nobody has simmed it for three months.
Nobody knows whether the proc is secretly incredible.
Somebody equips it because it looks good, hits something with it and discovers that perhaps everybody should suddenly care.
Within hours, screenshots spread. Databases update. Theorycrafters arrive. Guides appear. Eventually the mystery disappears, because mysteries in MMORPGs always do.
But for a little while, the knowledge belongs to the people actually playing the game.
Forever cannot recreate 2004’s internet.
It can, however, make us open the treasure chest before reading what is inside.
Post a Comment