For more than twenty years, World of Warcraft has maintained a peculiar tradition: if you want your sword enchanted, you may have to spend a considerable amount of time standing in a capital city looking for someone willing to do it.
Blacksmiths can sell weapons on the Auction House. Alchemists can fill their bags with potions and sell them whenever they please. Enchanters, meanwhile, must generally find another player, arrange a direct transaction, and apply their magic to that player's equipment.
It is a system that dates back to the earliest days of Azeroth. And with World of Warcraft: Forever launching November 4, players are increasingly questioning whether it still deserves a place in the game.
A growing discussion on Blizzard's official forums is calling for Enchanting Vellums, items that would allow Enchanters to place enchantments onto tradable scrolls. Those scrolls could then be sold through the Auction House, stored for later use, or mailed to alternate characters.
The suggestion has divided the community, and the argument is about considerably more than saving a few minutes in Trade Chat.
Enchanting Has an Economy Problem That Other Professions Don't
The debate gathered momentum on October 23, when a forum thread requesting Enchanting Vellums attracted support from players frustrated with the profession's traditional limitations.
One of the most common complaints concerns alternate characters. A Blacksmith can craft equipment for an alt, assuming the item is tradable. An Alchemist can prepare potions and send them through the mail. An Enchanter cannot simply prepare a weapon enchantment and send it to another character without a system such as vellums.
That frustration resurfaced in an October 28 discussion about Enchanting's lack of alt-friendly options, where players questioned why one profession should depend so heavily on direct player interaction.
The existing system does offer workarounds. Players can enchant eligible tradable equipment before mailing it, or ask a friend or guildmate to help. But neither approach provides the flexibility enjoyed by most other crafting professions.
Then there is the business of actually making gold.
Enchanting has always had an unusual economy. Players sacrifice potentially valuable equipment through disenchanting, collect expensive materials, and learn recipes that may take considerable effort to obtain. Yet selling the resulting service often means remaining available in a capital city, advertising in Trade Chat, and hoping someone needs precisely the enchantment being offered.
Vellums would change that. Enchanters could prepare finished enchantments in advance and list them on the Auction House, just as other crafters sell their products.
Supporters also point to automated advertising and invitation addons, arguing that modern Trade Chat is not always the charming marketplace that Classic enthusiasts remember. When players can automate much of the process of finding customers, the supposed social benefit becomes harder to defend.
Some have also raised concerns about scams and the risks associated with receiving gold directly from unfamiliar players.
The controversy arrives at an interesting moment. Forever is already introducing major profession interface improvements, including recipe tracking, searchable crafting windows, and better tools for sharing profession information.
Blizzard is also adding hundreds of recipes and new dungeon equipment with profession-specific bonuses. Clearly, crafting is supposed to matter more in Forever, not less.
Which makes the restrictions surrounding Enchanting particularly difficult to ignore.
But Would Vellums Remove Something Classic WoW Needs?
Not everyone considers those restrictions a problem.
For some players, finding an Enchanter is exactly the kind of interaction that distinguishes Classic World of Warcraft from its modern counterpart. You meet another adventurer, negotiate a price, gather your materials, and perhaps remember that person's name the next time you need something enchanted.
It is a small transaction, certainly, but Classic WoW was built around thousands of similarly small interactions. Finding someone to open a portal, helping a stranger defeat an elite enemy, or discovering that the same Blacksmith has been advertising rare recipes in Ironforge for three consecutive evenings.
Not every encounter needs to become a lifelong friendship to make the world feel inhabited.
Opponents also question what vellums would do to Enchanting prices. Moving enchantments onto the Auction House could encourage more aggressive competition, speculative trading, and pressure on players who previously relied on tips or direct negotiations.
That would not necessarily make enchantments cheaper or the profession more profitable for everyone. It would simply create a different marketplace.
The disagreement becomes especially interesting when considered alongside Forever's broader design philosophy.
Blizzard recently detailed a Camping system designed to bring players together in the open world, allowing adventurers to contribute profession-made objects and share temporary bonuses around campfires.
It is a deliberate attempt to encourage the kind of spontaneous cooperation that helped define the original game.
Removing the need to meet an Enchanter might appear to run against that philosophy. On the other hand, requiring someone to spend an evening repeating the same advertisement in Trade Chat is hardly the most imaginative way to encourage meaningful relationships.
And there may be room for compromise.
Some players have suggested account-bound vellums that would allow Enchanters to supply their own alts without opening an entirely new Auction House market. Others want a profession-finder system that preserves direct transactions while making it easier for customers to locate available crafters.
Neither proposal has been confirmed as an upcoming feature.
Blizzard has not announced plans to introduce Enchanting Vellums in WoW Forever, and the discussions remain community requests rather than confirmed changes. With launch approaching, players should not assume that the current system will be redesigned.
Nevertheless, the debate exposes one of Forever's most difficult design questions. Which inconveniences made Classic World of Warcraft memorable, and which ones were simply limitations that players learned to tolerate?
There is an important difference between a mechanic that encourages cooperation and one that merely makes players dependent on finding somebody else who happens to be online.
Enchanting Vellums would undoubtedly make life easier for many players. Whether that convenience would come at the expense of something valuable is less obvious.
Perhaps that is why this apparently minor profession argument has become such an interesting test of Forever's philosophy.
Twenty-two years after the original World of Warcraft launched, players are still debating whether finding someone to enchant their sword should be an adventure or a shopping trip.
And somewhere in Ironforge, an Enchanter is probably still advertising Crusader.
Sources: Blizzard Forums – Enchanting Vellums PLEASE (October 23, 2026) and Enchanting is not alt friendly? (October 28, 2026).

Post a Comment