Something interesting happened to Classic raiding almost immediately after the WoW Forever beta opened.
The number of active raiding characters recorded for both The Burning Crusade Anniversary and Mists of Pandaria Classic dropped sharply, while Blizzard was simultaneously dealing with so much demand for Forever that the company has now increased the beta population cap again.
That does not prove thousands of raiders abandoned their guilds specifically to play Forever. Raid-log statistics cannot tell us where somebody went after they stopped appearing in a log. But the timing is difficult to ignore.
TBC Anniversary Lost More Than 88,000 Logged Raiders
According to data highlighted by Wowhead from Ironforge.pro and Warcraft Logs, The Burning Crusade Anniversary recorded 212,821 raiding characters between September 8 and September 14.
During the following week, September 15 through September 21, that figure fell to 124,487.
That is 88,334 fewer characters appearing in raid activity during the week in which the Forever beta launched on September 17.
The timing is particularly notable because TBC Anniversary is not sitting at the very end of its content cycle. Players are currently progressing through Phase 3 with Black Temple and Mount Hyjal, while Zul'Aman and Sunwell Plateau still remain ahead.
Mists of Pandaria Classic also declined. Its recorded raiding population moved from 33,125 to 24,971 across the same comparison. MoP has a somewhat different situation, since Siege of Orgrimmar has already been available since June and its current content cycle is considerably more mature.
Meanwhile, Blizzard Keeps Making Room for More Forever Players
Forever is showing the opposite problem.
WoW Executive Producer Holly Longdale announced that Blizzard has increased the Forever beta population cap again, following continued demand and queue pressure. Blizzard also identified and fixed another issue that was unnecessarily filling login queues.
That comes after a launch where demand already overwhelmed several parts of the beta infrastructure. As we covered in our breakdown of Forever's chaotic beta launch, Blizzard had to expand backend capacity after Battle.net connections, database performance and world servers all encountered unexpected pressure.
Forever is therefore not struggling to find testers.
Quite the opposite.
But We Should Be Careful With the Conclusion
There is a very tempting headline here: “Forever stole Classic's players.”
The available data does not actually prove that.
Ironforge.pro population estimates are based on characters appearing in Warcraft Logs and PvP leaderboards. They are extremely useful for measuring activity, but they are not Blizzard subscription numbers and they do not identify why somebody stopped raiding. A character missing from one week could represent somebody playing Forever, taking a week off, clearing less content, changing characters or simply waiting for the next phase.
There are also unresolved questions around the future progression paths of both TBC Anniversary and MoP Classic, which may affect how invested players currently feel in those versions.
What we can say is simpler: Classic raid activity dropped sharply at almost exactly the moment Forever became available, while Forever itself continues requiring more capacity.
Forever Is Competing for the Same Kind of Player
That overlap makes sense.
Forever is not primarily competing with Retail by offering faster leveling and increasingly complex endgame systems. It is offering a rebuilt version of original Azeroth aimed directly at players who enjoy Classic's pacing, social structure, professions and fixed-size raiding.
Blizzard has already confirmed that every Forever raid tier will include both 10-player and 20-player content, while the game keeps a single raid difficulty and avoids Flex scaling. Our complete guide to Forever's changes shows just how directly the project speaks to an audience already comfortable living somewhere between Vanilla and later Classic expansions.
For now, the numbers show correlation rather than migration.
But if Classic raid activity stays lower while Forever's population keeps growing, this will become one of the more interesting trends to watch before the November 4 launch.
Azeroth may not be losing players.
They may simply be changing which version of Azeroth they log into.
Post a Comment